i only bring this up from personal experience, but i think your problem is all in altitude (like your boat mechanic was stating). i live in denver and have a 19" prop. even when at Powell (3633' when i was there this year) i don't think i'm gettin the WOT my setup is calilng for. i do get the best performance there but feel she has more in her.
i also want to drop to a 17". i boat anywhere from 5300 - 8500 feet (not counting powell). it's amazing what altitude will do to a motor. like my sleds for instance. in denver my sled runs like a stripped ass ape. get it up to 10k and it's another story.
i'm glad to hear the 17 worked out cause i've been waiting for the cash flow to be right to drop our 19 down to a 17 and i'm sure i'll get the same results.
bye the way what altitude are you at out of curiousity?
_________________
2006 Nissan Titan SE 6" Lift
2000 Four Winns 190 Horizon 5.0GL

