I'm about the only one here running the Hi-5. If you are happy with the overall performance of the 3bl 23P and still about 400 RPM or more below the top end of your WOT RPM throttle band, I would recommend getting the 23P in the 5 bl. If you are 200 RPM or less below the top end of the WOT RPM throttle band, I recommend you step up to a 25P (can you even get that pitch???). The smaller blade diameter lends to higher RPM for a given speed. I am running a 21P Hi-5 and get very similar top end/RPM as my 3 bl 19P.
My 21P SS will turn about 5000-5100 RPM at 52 MPH (GPS)
the 23P Hi 5 will do 5200 RPM at 50 MPH, but with much improved hole-shot.
Both are with 4 peeps, full fuel. I also noticed, the more I load down, the Hi-5 is affected less. Fully loaded I can still hit 48 MPH at about 4800 RPM, whereas the 3 bl will only hit about 46 MPH.
BTW...
Midwest Propeller is the best price in the biz!
_________________
Walt B
"Debt-Charged"Black '07 H210SS6.2L Bravo One turning a 21P HIFive
Wakeboard Tower with Perfect Pass Stargazer version
Missouri River; Kansas City, Mo.