Rick sorry to hear of your trouble, I think the root of it, is in one of your older posts....when you changed the manifolds...I thought I saw rust in the exhaust port...which can happen when that joint leaks between the manifold and the riser. You said the boat was in salt water and if it was in salt the whole time before you got it, then they were past replacement time for sure if they were the originals. Here in salt we don't usually go more than 5-7 years on a set. Unless you have full closed cooling, or stainless manifolds from Hi Tek marine in Australia its just the way it is in salt water. Look at the pix, you can see rust in the exhaust ports in the cylinder head and I bet you have a sticky valve or two that has rust on the valve stem. If its not too bad you can get the heads done over the winter. Your post:
viewtopic.php?f=6&t=12833&hilit=manifolds&start=0In your flickr pix you have a pic of the engine with the risers still installed. The one on the right hand side of the engine as you face it (port side of the boat) has rust stains on the outside. Often when you see that on the outside, its leaking on the inside.
I also enlarged the photo of the engine with the same riser taken off the port side manifold, its a bit blurry but I thought I saw rust in the exhaust passage. All that should be there is carbon if you have rust then water has been getting into a cylinder. Not enough to hydrolock, but enough to rust exhaust valve stems especially.
Here's my engine during the last manifold change in 2011...you can see into the exhaust ports and there is no rust only carbon...this engine has been in salt water every season, moored in it 6 months out of the year since 2002, it was trailered in salt before that and before that it came from the Midwest.
https://www.dropbox.com/s/u3w9g3qvuxycb ... 1.jpg?dl=0Here's what the second set of one piece OMC manifold/risers looked like after 5.5 years of use, see how on one side one of the 4 water passages is clogged up. I could have used these again by rodding out the opening, but I put a new set on instead...
https://www.dropbox.com/s/co8mqd4vi8qze ... w.jpg?dl=0Now these are NLA, so I have to do something different the next time I replace (about 2-3 years). I am thinking of going with the Hi Tek stainless manifolds, because by then I may repower with a new crate engine and I have never liked the old style Merc/Volvo riser gasket design, there is not that much sealing surface, its easy for salt water to corrode the cast iron there and then you get leaks. Merc's dry joint system is an improvement because the water passage and the exhaust gas passage is much more separated. But they use a different outlet diameter size and that would require a lot of adapting to make it work on an OMC/Volvo engine.
So far my engine has had 3 sets of these manifolds on it and never had water in a cylinder ever. I wish I could still get them. To me the standard inboard manifold/riser gasket design is just a very bad compromise. Failure prone in salt water.
People often ask me why I keep my old boat and don't get a 'newer' one. Well around here unless is like 3 years old or less, there is not much point unless it has full closed cooling or a merc with the newer style manifolds. I'd rather start again with the old boat and a new engine set up exactly how I want it (closed cooling, stainless manifolds) than start with someone else's problems.....
So OK after you relax, work it through....do another comp test....this time put a bit of oil in the cyls that are low to make sure its the valves, or do a leak down test better yet that will tell you exactly what it is. I had that same feeling when I was winterizing the boat in 2005, went to pull out the rear seat....and my foot nearly went through the floor.....that lead to....a...BIG JOB....personally I'd rather pull a set of heads anyday....than do that again.....
https://www.dropbox.com/s/e316zo94sig9y ... r.jpg?dl=0https://www.dropbox.com/s/v24fgzc4yvwm6 ... W.jpg?dl=0https://www.dropbox.com/s/pes4wf5zt63mx ... n.jpg?dl=0https://www.dropbox.com/s/g1rnp0kl1gqpz ... g.jpg?dl=0