I have a 258 witha a Lewmar "sprint 400" factory installed. I have installed
the same one on my 24' polar. They worked like a charm and never had any
problems. I din't have any experance with Maxwell, but it was an upgrade
for my boat. I like Lewmar and when my dies I'm replacing it with a V700.
The bigest thing is the backing plate and anckor locker space. Buying the right
rode is another big thing. Make sure you get what the manufacture recomands
for the rode, If you don't then you going to get alot of tangles and problems.
I've installed a windlass on more that one boat so if you need info I will be glad to help.
It saved my marrige and my wifes back!

I would never owne a boat without
one again.
Mark W.