Ok, I am officially an idiot! Just bought myself a nice pair of Sperry Top-Sider Largo slip-on boat shoes, size 9.5. Like these:

I usually wear a 10.5, but they were huge on me. They didn't have a 10 and the 9.5 length seemed about right so I bought them. Wore them around this evening, went to the pub with the admiral for dinner. About half way through dinner, it became obvious that I need a size 10. If you were looking for a nice pair of boat shoes, I can sell you these at a discount after about 2 hours of wear. Just purchased for $70. Yours for $50. I'm usually not real big on buying/selling used shoes, but these really are not used. Love the shoe, just need the right size. I apologize in advance if selling used boat shoes on the forum offends anyone!