Paul I. wrote:
I am tiring to understand!! I have always owned a Mer. with a closed system which means that you don't need to drain the block. (and this boat too V258) Two different dealers have told me the same thing, (for open & closed systems) that is. As long as for run the AF though the engine (by the drive or Volvos's intake house) you do not need to do anything else. This will drive the water out and leave the AF in in the engine and out drive.
Why would this do/result "Do not be tempted into using the winterizing tanks that use the suck water up the drive method, that can result in a cracked block..." The 2 pumps should take the AF and pass it though everything in the system. No?? As it would if you were in the ocean/lake on a day out.
In the past, I have always drained every thing too! But, the 2 dealers said basically, nothing wrong in doing that, it is more work. They let the engine suck in the AF and your done. I understand back filling it & agree with it, thats one reason way I have a closed system.
Lou, can you please explain?
OK keep in mind, I am saying this in relation to a raw water cooled (open system, no heat exchanger) engine. The issue is that if you run it on the water hose on a cool fall day, the engine may not get hot enough to cause the thermostat to open fully long enough to let the raw water out of the engine to be replaced with antifreeze. The AF will go straight into the manifolds and out the exhaust, but until the thermostat opens, there will still be raw water in the block/heads. Which will then freeze and crack the block/heads.
With a closed cooling system, this method can be used because there is no issue with the thermostat. Some people will remove the thermostat, or drain the engine first to use this method. For me I'd rather just drain it, and then back fill the engine and manifolds through the hoses, safer, uses less AF, no risk to burning the impeller if it does not pull in the AF easily, and no freeze damage risk most important of all. This method is VERY risky with an raw water cooled engine. Can you tell for sure when your thermostat opens, if you don't have an IR temp gun, I bet you can't. And even then, it has to stay open long enough, to let the water out of the block...
The dealers are giving BAD advice, they do it that way, but they sometimes use a big trough, that they submerge the drive in full of AF. This gets heated by the engine, and because of that, the thermostat will open and stay open long enough to get the engine full of AF. Since the AF is re-circulated, it stays hot, or probably at least 80-90
degrees. Thats how they winterize many boats in one day. The water from your water hose is quite cold by comparison. That keeps the thermo from opening, and traps raw water in the engine....
Make sense??