I just removed two old transducers from the transom of my recently purchased 1987 215 Sundowner. Only one was still connected and that to a 17 year old depth finder which is being retired. I'm going to install a modern unit with navigation and side-scanning capability but meanwhile I have to deal with holes in the transom.
The old transducers were poorly installed...."Bubba" used silicone which I'll have to clean up before I can contemplate anything else.

What I'd like to hear are your recommendations for dealing with the empty holes. I was thinking that after removing the silicone I would grind a small concave depression at the opening of each screw hole then fabricate small metal plates from aluminum or stainless and drill them to match the screw patterns - then I would take a quality marine caulking, squirt some in the holes and on the underside of the plate and screw the plate down, squeezing the caulk into a gasket. The tiny concave depression would form an O-ring of sorts around the screws. I could also accomplish pretty much the same thing using fender washers at each hole but you get the idea. One wild card is having to drill additional holes for the new transducer but until I settle on a unit I have no clue what impact it will have.
Do you have any other ideas? I'm very open to suggestions.
Tim