Just so I'm clear here.... I would never purposely make a false distress call for any reason nor would any other responsible boater here. I know that they are for use during distress situations only and that penalties are severe.
I think what is being said here is that the discharging of a flare and/or a flare gun in a safe manner during the fireworks portion of the 4th of July festivities would seemingly go unnoticed as such and merely be perceived as one of the many firework displays.
In my opinion, as long as its incorporated into a fireworks display, its a harmless practice and probably the safest way to dispose of them as well as familiarizing ones self with the operation and feel of their flare launching devise.
In my particular case, I've been boating for 20+ years and have amassed quite a surplus of 'outdated' flares. Even after disposing of these 12 flares, I still have 8 more 'outdated' ones on board along with the required 12 current dated flares, which I feel is more than enough.
My fear of the 'water soaking' method is that what if they were to completely dry out. Does this make them potentially explosive again? Just a thought.
In the end, my local Police department did take them off my hands but only after a major grilling as to how they came to be in my possession and what I planned to do with them.
Sorry for the rant but I just didn't want this thread to be taken out of context.