The issue with changing #blades, and large pitch changes is as blade count goes up, prop diameter goes down. Case in point, my 3 blade 19P is about 15 3/8" dia and gives me 51 MPH at 5200 RPM. My HiFive (5 blade 21P) is 13 5/8" dia and gives me 50 MPH at 5200 RPM. The 5 gives much improved hole shot, and better throttle response in the low-mid range for my Prefect Pass cruise control, but is definately not for top-end or cruising.
I agree that you 4 blade option should be a good prop for your set-up as far as speed and RPM, and at a fair price. You will feel in improvement in the bottom end, but don't think you will increase your cruise speed, or top end. I believe you would see your most desired performance (no tubing, skiing, etc) from a 3blade 21P, or even 23P. But keep in mind, even going from the 19P to a 23P you are only going to change top end by about 5 mph.
IMO, if you ain't over-revving it and getting the otherwise desired performance, leave it alone!
It soulds like you have already used a
prop slip calc.
hope that helps!
_________________
Walt B
"Debt-Charged"Black '07 H210SS6.2L Bravo One turning a 21P HIFive
Wakeboard Tower with Perfect Pass Stargazer version
Missouri River; Kansas City, Mo.